LLOC

Insights

LLOC Advisory

2 min read

Cloud or in-house?

Neither answer is right for everything. A plain-language decision guide with a five-year cost comparison for a ten-person business.

Cloud is one of the most overused words in business technology. In plain terms it means your data and software run on someone else’s servers, accessed over the internet. Microsoft 365 is cloud. A server under a desk in your office is on-premises.

Most organisations already use cloud services without noticing. Xero, MYOB, HubSpot, your booking system and your email are all cloud services. The question is not cloud versus no cloud. It is which things should be in the cloud and which should stay local.

The five-year cost

For a ten-person business, running your own server typically costs $25,000 to $55,000 over five years. That includes hardware, setup, annual maintenance, power, cooling, backup hardware and the replacement when the server reaches end of life in year four or five.

Microsoft 365 Business Premium for ten people costs about $22 AUD per user per month, or roughly $13,200 over five years. Add cloud backup at $5 per user per month and you are at $16,200, with no hardware to replace, no power bills and no maintenance calls at 11pm.

The cloud wins on cost for most organisations once every variable is included. The exceptions are businesses that process very large amounts of local data, or specialist compliance requirements that mandate on-premises storage.

What belongs in the cloud

The clearest candidates are services that benefit from being reachable anywhere, on any device, by anyone on your team.

  • Email and calendars: Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace.
  • File storage and sharing: SharePoint, OneDrive or Google Drive.
  • Accounting: Xero, MYOB Business or QuickBooks Online, with live bank feeds and access for your accountant.
  • Video and chat: Teams or Zoom.
  • Customer management: HubSpot, Salesforce or similar.

What is better kept in-house

  • Large video editing or CAD work that needs local storage and a GPU. Moving 100 GB files to a cloud editor is impractical.
  • Manufacturing and industrial control systems that need millisecond response times.
  • Regulated data with sovereignty requirements, though the major providers now have Australian data centres that satisfy most of them.

The honest answer for most organisations

Move email, files and collaboration to Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace. Keep your network equipment on site, because switches, Wi-Fi and firewalls have to be. Assess everything else case by case on cost, performance and compliance.

Do this today

List every server and piece of hardware you run and what it does. For each one ask whether a cloud service could replace it, what it would cost and what you would lose. Anything over five years old and due for replacement is almost always cheaper to replace with cloud than with new hardware.

Start here

Want this handled for you?

Every article ends with something to do. If you would rather we did it, a practice lead replies within one business day.